John From Cincinnati: Web Poll

The surf noir series John From Cincinnati has been running on HBO for more than a month now, and to date, the reviews have been mixed in the mainstream press. While some critics love it, others are convinced director David Milch of Deadwood fame has finally lost his very creative mind once and for all. But we want to know what you think. Which of these responses best reflects your opinion of HBO’s attempt to portray a mysterious character entering the lives of a family of screwed up surfers trying to put their lives back together?