search
   MENU /
NEWS

ATTACK EYEWITNESS: Longtime Solana Beach Surfer Ira Opper Describes Attack

Interview by
Brad Melekian
Senior Editor SURFER Magazine


A man was fatally attacked by a shark this morning in Solana Beach. While details are still unfolding, we got this first-person account from long-time Solana Beach surfer Ira Opper, who was at the beach at the time of the attack.

Related Links

View photos from the attack.
Read the full story.

You know, it was my morning surf check at Pillbox. All of a sudden, somebody—I thought they said somebody had a heart attack, and they asked the public works person to remove their truck from the beach access because they were there cleaning up. All of the sudden, you hear all the sirens, they went up toward Tabletops and then eventually one of the ambulances pulled in to Fletcher Cove and then there were about three or four people in wetsuits sort of in shock. And then a girl comes running up the ramp screaming, "He's bleeding to death! He's bleeding to death!" The paramedic calmed her down, saying, "There's people there, they came down from Tabletop, I'm on the radio, they're doing everything they can." They calmed her down. Within three to five more minutes, the lifeguards and the paramedics had the victim in the back of one of the lifeguard trucks, they brought him up to Fletcher Cove and probably for the next twenty minutes, they performed CPR. Administered whatever medicine that they do in that situation, and they continued doing CPR. Mercy Airvac landed on the beach, they came up and within 15-20 minutes of CPR, they sort of backed off. He bled to death. His whole lower body—wetsuit, legs—were shredded. I asked the Captain of the Lifeguards what he thinks happened and he said a "very, very large shark" attacked. I talked to another gentleman who was walking up the beach actually before it happened. It turned out he had walked up the beach and saw a sea lion on the beach that looked very distressed. Something you don't see too often around here, especially on the beach.

The triathlete crew were training. They said it was outside the surf line, so it was somewhere between Tabletops and Fletcher Cove. Older guy. Looked like he was in his late 50s, fairly great shape, fairly big guy.


    - advertisement -
 

This was about 7:30. Right in that window. Just down for my morning surf check. It was nice and quiet and then all of a sudden all hell broke loose.

I know the lifeguards began clearing the beaches, and the State Parks started clearing the water. And then there's lifeguards out there and helicopters and everything else.

Reader Comments 
Posted Fri Apr25, 2008, 1:30 PM — By NBCSandiego.com
Live coverage of this story available on NBCSandiego.com. Here is link for Friday 10:15 - 11 a.m. http://www.nbcsandiego.com/videostream/11724377/detail.html Link for more on this story: http://www.nbcsandiego.com/news/15993008/detail.html
Posted Fri Apr25, 2008, 3:07 PM — By David Falkenau
David Falkenau, English and Science Teacher at the Army and Navy Academy, Carlsbad, CA (and self proclaimed elasmobranchologist and Great White Shark expert) says: I've been studying the Great White Shark since I was a child. I am 34 years old now, and I have my own theory behind an attack like this. I think the water is getting colder and the Whites are moving back down here (So-Cal) to their natural birthing ground off Blacks and that long stretch of deep water basin / Canyon in La Jolla. Everyone knows about the juvenile Whites that have made their home just south of the power plant at San Onofre. They have made trail 1 and the trails camping area their home, and I would not be surprized that it was one of these that initiated the attack. You must also realize that Great Whites attack with a "bite-and-spit" method where they will sometimes circle their prey for long periods of time before initiating a single bite, and then they will circle their prey and wait for it to bleed to
Posted Fri Apr25, 2008, 3:10 PM — By Al Brenneka
We would like to extend deepest sympathies to the family and friends of the person who didn't survive the shark attack. If there is anything we can ever do to assist you in any way, Contact Us! We have formed an organization for Shark Attack Survivors operated by Shark Attack Survivors at www.sharkattacksurvivors.com. We are the only organization that provides resources, information, and assistance for past, present, and future shark attack victims and their families. If you were involved or know someone who was involved in a shark attack, Please visit and contact us at www.sharkattacksurvivors.com. SharkAttackSurvivors.com also has pages and pages of shark attack information to help others avoid being attacked, visit us. Director Al Brenneka Shark Attack Survivors
Posted Fri Apr25, 2008, 3:39 PM — By Jim Parkhurst
I find it very interesting that the eyewitness noticed a seal lion DISTRESSED and ON THE BEACH. I would bet the shark was hunting it and mistook the swimmer for the sea lion.
Posted Fri Apr25, 2008, 5:28 PM — By Tim Senneff
I was surfing alone off Trevor's house in Del Mar yesterday at 12 noon just 3/4 mile from the attack and it felt spooky as well and even had sharks on my mind. Came in after 1 hour. My friend said he saw a legitimate double shark fin off Boat Ramp at shores on Tuesday paddling up to Shores. Not just one of those many "friendly breeding" sharks that congregate down there in Spring/Summer. Keep looking upward always!
Posted Fri Apr25, 2008, 7:51 PM — By Alison
AHHH! did he die?
Posted Fri Apr25, 2008, 8:24 PM — By drudown
Sorry, you do not seem to be much of an expert on White sharks, Mr. Falkenau. First, nobody has ever seen a White shark give birth much less conclusively know where White sharks' "birthing grounds" are. Your speculation has no evidentiary support. Second, the notion that a juvenile White shark was the culprit is likewise flat out false. Juvenile White sharks primarily feed on fish, not pinnipeds or marine mammals. Besides. Here, the bite radius was 22". As far as the "bite and spit" theory is concerned, this attack tends to show the overlooked dynamic that human beings are the only prey item that comes to the rescue before the victim can bleed to death under the known "bite, spit and wait" predation pattern. How's this: adult White sharks prefer seals but are still generalist feeders and humans are digestible prey. Humans and their precursors have been a White shark prey item for over 2 million years. So in 2008 it is not a case of mistaken identity. It is Nature
Posted Sat Apr26, 2008, 12:43 AM — By Kyle drahuschak
Hey I would also like to send my sympathy to the family morning their loss. I work in La Jolla Shore doing kayak tours and their were two tour guides that claimed to have spotted a great white near La Jolla Caynon!!!!! I personally havent seen any thing. but there are an abundance of sea lions at the La Jolla Sea Caves.It seems to be very possible that a great white would be attracted to this prey. Especially with the La jolla and the scripps under water canyons being close to shore. I'm sure this isn't the last shark alert we'll have in southern california before september.
Posted Sat Apr26, 2008, 1:32 AM — By David Falkenau
Don't be so quit to slam my post. most of my post was cut off because it exceeded the 1024 characters. go to www.artisansurfdesigns.blogspot.com and read the rest of it, and then you can slam me. Okay Mr. Drudown? There Always has to be a Mr. Negative out there, doesn't there???
Posted Sat Apr26, 2008, 1:34 AM — By David Falkenau
Don't be so quick to slam my post. Most of my post was cut off because it exceeded the 1024 characters. Go to www.artisansurfdesigns.blogspot.com and read the rest of it, and then you can slam me. Okay Mr. Drudown? There Always has to be a Mr. Negative out there, doesn't there???
Posted Sat Apr26, 2008, 8:56 AM — By C. Carcarias
A couple of years ago there was a big, old sea lion beached on a very public beach here in Santa Barbara. He refused to go back in the water, but finally some passer-bys forced him back in. He was there again the next day with a massive shark bite across his entire body. Moral - pay attention to the animals.
Posted Sat Apr26, 2008, 2:06 PM — By drudown
Fair enough. After reading your entire post I'm convinced you know even less about White sharks. First, you incorrectly state the last White shark fatality in SD County was 1959 when in fact M. V. Emster was killed by a White shark in 1994. Second, you incorrectly attribute mammalian hunting patterns to White sharks. Third, there is nothing "irregular" about human vibration patterns in the sea that triggers attacks- it is simply human, like a fingerprint. This underscores why people are rarely attacked, i.e., White sharks know what we are and don't prey on us. But when a human has its leg bitten off, the White shark is feeding itself. Facts are facts.
Posted Sat Apr26, 2008, 6:00 PM — By Yannick
Dear all, From France where i live, i was once circled by a shark. Didn't stayed long enough in the water to guess what it was exactly... Indeed, the key fact here seem to be the distressed sea lion on the beach. For the lifeguard i am, this is a big teaching, if only you can the sea lion check before entering the water. How about these individual electric defense stick i heard of some years ago ? Is it efficient ? Any chance to plug it on shark nets off the beaches ? Deepest thoughts to the victim's family. Yannick. www.CathaySeas.com
Posted Sat Apr26, 2008, 6:46 PM — By Mermark1 New Jersey
I think, and I am not saying that it is true, that all the bait fish are being caught by commercial fisherman, this tends to lead the sharks in closer to land, to search for food. This guy was at the wrong place at the right time for the shark. These sharks are very dangerous, and will eat anything to survive. My Thoughts and Prayers go out to his family for their tragic loss.
Posted Sat Apr26, 2008, 7:34 PM — By ithappens
Seems all these theories may resonate with the facts in some way. From what I have pieced together and suspect after surfing the sharky waters of humboldt and santa cruz county for over ten years and personally knowing 6 people who have either been attacked or near an attack. It would seem there was a pod of athletes training (swimming) near by - the elder man - most likely slower was trailing by himself - very much the same pattern as an elder slow meaty seal which is the usual prey of whites. You defintitley pick up the spook in the water - i have felt it on more than one occasion and left the water and have one friend who even felt that spook - pulled his feet up onto his board and still got hit - landing in the jaws and being spit free - most likely due to his fiberglass and lack of fat body. I always watch the seals- they commonly seek land when whitey is about. Wherever there is seals and deep water - youre gonna have whites - welcome to the wilderness. Maybe the line up will clea
Posted Sun Apr27, 2008, 7:52 AM — By Hank Eisenhour
Sympathies sent to family and friends from Texas surfers.
Posted Mon Apr28, 2008, 5:31 AM — By Bev Lockhart
I'm stuck in WA till June, and I'm looking forward to getting back in the water when I get back to San Diego for the Ocean Beach Street Fair June 28. Being attacked by a shark is my biggest fear in life, but it hasn't ever kept me out of the water! I no longer eat shark, however, coz I certainly wouldn't want the karmic fallout to bite me in the A$$!!! A warning to the women. (I learned about this when I lived in Hawaii; there is a major tiger shark breeding ground right off of Maui): Stick to a pool when you're experiencing the Red Tide (monthly flow). Sharks can smell blood from miles away. I had to give up watching JAWS movies, too, especially after hearing the duh-duh, duh-duh (Jaws soundtrack) in my head when swimming in an 18-foot-deep diving pool with no lights on one night at the club while I was waiting for my dad! I knew it was ludicrous, but I got the hell outta the pool till my daddy showed up that night! I have had sharks brush up against my legs in the brackish bays in FL
Posted Mon Apr28, 2008, 10:03 AM — By Evan Zulich
deepest of sympathy to the family members and loved ones of the deceased. anyone trying to put their two cents in should first acknowledge that. luckily for me and other people in my area, hawaii has not experienced all too many shark inflicted fatalities... never the less, the opinions and "stats" posted on this site are tragic. respect first, inspect later. nothing but aloha from hilo on the big island, hawaii.
Posted Mon Apr28, 2008, 11:24 AM — By Patrick
Two years ago I predicted to my adult son that there would be an attack off the North San Diego County coastline soon. The reason is simple: Seals and sea lions are protected species and they are no longer allowed to be killed my fishermen like they have been over the last century. Anybody boating by the bouys off the coast of Carlsbad will know what I am talking about, they are thick out there and fight each other for an empty spot to "sun" themselves (or to get away from the sharks)on the bouys. This will not be the last attack, in my opinion there will be another one within two years, until the population of sea lions is significantly reduced .
Posted Tue Apr29, 2008, 2:11 AM — By David Miller
My sympaties to the family of Dr Martin. As tragic as this attack was, from what I understand this was a man who loved what he was doing and had a great love for the water. I am glad the family is not the type to be demanding that this shark be hunted down and killed for doing something that comes naturally to it.
Posted Tue Apr29, 2008, 2:26 AM — By Greg
My prayers and thoughts go out to the Martin family. I've been surfing in San Diego since the 80's. Mainly at Del Mar, it's the adjacent beach to Solana Beach. I pray every time I go out for a session, knowing that it's possible I may not be coming out of the water alive, if at all. I guess that's when you know you love a sport. If someone were to asked me to go mountain biking through Africa, I would tell them they were nuts! Because of all the animals that could kill you, roaming free through the plains. Form some reason (right or wrong) many surfers, including myself, want to believe that the swimming/surfing in the ocean is different than walking/biking through Africa. You won't be forgotten Dr. David Martin. 15th Street Surfer, Greg...
Posted Wed Apr30, 2008, 2:35 PM — By Jamie
Prayers for the Martin family and those that were training with him.Thanks to the First Responders that did what thet were trained to do to keep Dr.Martin alive. Heads up out there!
Posted Thu May 1, 2008, 2:30 PM — By David Falkenau
Well, Drudown... My statements are / were based on FACTS. You may want to re-research YOUR FACTS. The 1994 attack has been FACTUALLY documented as a case where they could not prove that she was attacked as a cause of death and therefore theorized that a white shark bit her leg off post-mortem... so Robert Pamperin is still the last one to get attacked, and that was in 1959... However, some even speculated that it was staged and or even a Killer whale... which I doubt. As for your Human vibrations comment... Show me a human that swims with a perfect and steady patten not making any spalshes or irregularities when they swim or splash or stop amd are treading water... wounded fish and swimmers have both been compared and the vibrations ARE IN FACT VERY SIMILAR. Furthermore your comment about my "mammalian" comment is also just mere rambling on your part. There was a tag and study done in Australian waters where the sharks that were ALL tagged, worked together in a group very similar to wolve
Posted Wed May 7, 2008, 3:01 AM — By Dominic
My sympaties to the family of Dr Martin from Germany. I surfed at this spot for 3 years while I stayed in the US. Beauteousness and actual life danger lie so close together! I am sorry for you guys. I hope that the family will be able to accept and forgive one day!
Posted Wed May 7, 2008, 4:00 PM — By ryan halkett
very sad.wrong place at the wrong time. the shark was probably lost and very hungry. rarely do sharks attack humans. i surf with then everyday in south africa. its natures way...
Posted Fri May 9, 2008, 12:00 PM — By xxx
First of all, my sympathy to the family of Dr. Martin. Second, drudown and falkenau, i don't think this is the right occasion/page for a cockfight. Everyone interested in great whites can read about them and make up their own mind. Not much is known yet and facts can be contradictory. Speculations are made easily. Why not spend some money for shark research instead of just bawling seals beach in La Jolla should be opened for humans as seals could attract w sharks?! Sure, where the hell is a beach in SoCal where that no human calls his own? Seals have to spread everywhere and so will the sharks. I surfed there myself and one day 2007 saw a seal w/o a head on the beach. If you commit to the water, you commit to the risk! Now, have fun driving your car.

Add Comment
Name (Required):
Email (Required, will not be shown to public):
Comment (Required, max chars: 1024):
You have characters left.
 

Type the characters you see in this picture

  

    general discussion
    design forum
    industry news
Aug 8
Police raid mayor's home and kill his dogs.
Aug 8
GWS Presents: Stanleys / Oil Piers
Aug 8
Our Boy Koa Smith Is Going Places
Aug 8
Have it your way? Only in Hawaii...
Aug 8
BRONZED
Aug 8
IF YOU'RE CONFUZZLED...
Aug 8
Big Guy Tri dims?
Aug 8
Shaping tools for sale!
Aug 8
WYD Board Sale - 2 Bonzers and 1 Bulkley Pintail
Aug 7
JJR: Lokbox R5/R8 quad
Aug 8
RED BULL NIGHT RIDERS TO HOST TOP EAST COAST SURFERS IN ATLANTIC CITY
Aug 8
THE DAILY HABIT: Ryan Smith, Lindsay Robertson and Ian Walsh Featured
Aug 8
RIP CURL GROMSEARCH EXPLODES ON NEW SMYRNA BEACH FLORIDA THIS SATURDAY!
Aug 7
2008 SACRED CRAFT CONSUMER SURFBOARD EXPO SOLD OUT!
Aug 7
Big Wednesday 30th Anniversary Screening Slated for 2008 NY Surf Film Fest
Aug 7
Enzian Theater Will Show Cut of Kelly Slater Statue Documentary
Aug 7
Memorial for Surf Film Pioneer Bud Browne - Aug 25
Aug 7
FUEL TV ANNOUNCES STELLAR AUGUST PROGRAMMING LINEUP
More Industry News...

 

   
Here's the fastest way to bring home the best magazine covering the surfing lifestyle -- Surfer Magazine -- at no risk! During this special online offer, you can get a TRIAL ISSUE and receive 11 more (a total of 12 issues) for only $14.97! You save 68% off the cover price

If you choose not to subscribe, just write "cancel" on your invoice, send it back and owe nothing. Either way, the trial issue is yours to keep -- without obligation. Just complete the information below, and click on submit.


GIVE A GIFT
 
Email:
First Name:
Last Name:
Address Line 1:
Address Line 2:
City:
State: Zip:
Select a payment option:
Charge my credit card
Bill me later
Do you have a promotional coupon code?
Enter Code:
Please send me special offers and exclusive promotions from Surfer's premiere partners.
 

You need to upgrade your Flash Player
Click here to download Flash



Surf Offers
Boat Trips
Surf Music
Surf Clothes
Surf Camps
Surfing DVDs - Videos
Board Shorts
Surf Forecasts
NauticExpo-Surf   Equipment
Free Surf Cams


North Shore Beach Rentals


SIGN UP FOR OUR
FREE NEWSLETTER


 SURFER | WAVEWATCH | FANTASY SURFER | SNOW | SKATE  | SURFING  | BIKE | POWDER | CANOEKAYAK 

Subscribe | Advertise | Contact Us | Shop | Jobs | Retail Sign Up
Copyright ©2008 SOURCE INTERLINK MEDIA™. All rights reserved.